Legal Liability of Maritime Carriers in the Gulf States: A Comparative Study and Judicial-Legislative Analysis
Legal Topics

Introduction

Given the strategic geographical location of the Arab Gulf states and the flourishing maritime trade passing through their pivotal ports, a need has emerged to regulate the relationship between maritime carriers and cargo owners through precise maritime legislation that aligns with international standards.

The liability of the maritime carrier for cargo damage or delayed delivery is among the most contentious legal issues, particularly given the growing volume of imports and exports and the multiplicity of contracting parties. Against this backdrop, this legal paper presents a comparative study covering the UAE, Saudi Arabia, and Qatar, featuring an analysis of notable judicial rulings and practical legal recommendations for mitigating contractual risks.

First: The Legislative Basis for the Liability of the Maritime Carrier

🇦🇪 United Arab Emirates

Pursuant to Federal Decree-Law No. (43) of 2023 concerning the Maritime Law, the legal framework has been updated to align with international conventions and best practices. Key provisions include:

Article 184

Goods shall be deemed lost if not delivered within sixty days from the date fixed for delivery, unless the carrier proves that the non-delivery is due to an extraneous cause beyond its control.

Article 185

The carrier is liable for damage or delay proven to have occurred during the period of carriage, unless it is proven that the carrier took all reasonable measures to avoid or minimize the damage.

Article 186

The contracting carrier remains liable for the performance of obligations, even if it entrusts them to an actual carrier, and shall be jointly and severally liable unless otherwise agreed.

🇸🇦Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

The Saudi Maritime Trade Law (Royal Decree No. M/33 of 2022) regulates the relationship between parties to maritime transport contracts. Its key provisions include:

Article 79

The carrier is liable for any damage to or loss of the goods from the time of their receipt until their delivery, unless it is proven that the cause is *force majeure* or the fault of the shipper.

Article 80

The carrier’s liability is negated if it proves that it took all measures that a diligent carrier would take to avoid or minimize the damage.

🇶🇦The State of Qatar

Qatari Commercial Law No. (27) of 2006 continues to serve as the primary reference for regulating the liability of the maritime carrier.

Article 239

The carrier is obliged to deliver the goods in the condition in which they were received, unless it is proven that the damage or loss is attributable to an external cause or force majeure.

Article 241

The carrier may not be exempted from liability in cases of gross negligence, fraud, or bad faith.

Secondly: An Analytical Comparison of Gulf Systems

ItemUAE (2023)Saudi Arabia (2022)Qatar (2006)
Liability Commencement CriterionFrom receipt of goods until delivery + 60-day grace periodFrom receipt until deliveryFrom receipt until delivery
Conditions for Exemption from LiabilityProof of an external cause + reasonable measuresDemonstrating that reasonable measures have been takenClearly establishing the external cause
Liability for the acts of othersJoint and several liability with the actual carrierContractual liability based on the agreementNot presumed except in the event of an actual breach
Gross NegligenceThe carrier is under no circumstances exempt from liability for it.An exemption clause is ineffective in cases of gross negligence.This is explicitly stated in Article 241.
Limits of liabilityMay be agreed uponDetermined by the executive regulationsAgreement is permissible, provided it does not violate public policy

Third: Real-world judicial precedents

💼 UAE – Dubai Court of Cassation (170/2021)

Incident: Cargo damage caused by seawater during transport. Outcome: Rejection of the *force majeure* defense due to the absence of a technical report, and confirmation of the carrier’s liability to compensate for the damage.

💼 Saudi Arabia – Commercial Appeal (2147/T/2023)

Incident: Unjustified delay in the delivery of a shipment imported to Jeddah Islamic Port. Ruling: The carrier is ordered to pay compensation due to its breach of the notification obligation and the delivery plan.

💼 Qatar – QICAC Arbitration Center (2020/14)

Facts: A delay in unloading caused damage to foodstuffs. Outcome: The carrier was ordered to pay compensation, despite the existence of an exemption clause in the contract.

Fourth: Specialized legal recommendations for shipping companies

Digitally documenting all stages of the sea voyage.

Drafting contractual terms and bills of lading with complete legal professionalism.

Including an arbitration clause to avoid lengthy litigation.

Understanding the limits of liability exemptions and exercising caution regarding contractual restrictions.

Review of each contract by a legal advisor specializing in maritime law.

🔎 Why Choose “Horus Legal Solutions”?

A legal team with deep regional expertise in Gulf and international maritime laws

Legal representation in maritime disputes before the DIAC, ICC, and Gulf courts

Professional drafting of maritime transport contracts and international shipping terms

Ongoing risk-mitigation consultancy in both Arabic and English

A strong track record in complex commercial disputes involving shipping and marine insurance

“We do more than just protect your operations—we safeguard your business reputation and international rights.”

❓ Frequently Asked Questions (Q&A)

Is the carrier liable for delay if there is no physical damage?

Yes, delay constitutes a breach of contract and may give rise to a claim for compensation if loss or damage is proven.

Can the carrier be fully exempted from liability?

No; under the laws of the UAE, Saudi Arabia, and Qatar, any clause exempting the carrier from liability in cases of gross negligence or fraud is invalid.

Are electronic bills of lading recognized as evidence?

Yes; under the new UAE Maritime Law and other relevant laws, electronic bills of lading are recognized provided their authenticity is established.

Which authority has jurisdiction in the event of a dispute?

The competent judicial authority, unless there is a valid arbitration clause (e.g., DIAC or ICC).

Scroll to Top
This site is registered on wpml.org as a development site. Switch to a production site key to remove this banner.